Cane ban improved student behaviour, say researchers

Written by

in

For years, the argument for bringing back the cane in Kenyan schools has rested on a familiar concern: that children have become increasingly unruly because teachers can no longer use physical punishment to enforce discipline.

But a new study is challenging that assumption, suggesting outlawing corporal punishment may have helped reduce, rather than fuel, aggressive behaviour among children.

The findings came at a time when some lawmakers are pushing for a review of the ban, arguing growing cases of indiscipline and attacks on teachers point to the need for tougher disciplinary measures in schools.

However, researchers who tracked children’s behaviour over nine years found aggression among Kenyan children declined after the country outlawed corporal punishment in 2001.

The study, which followed 1,086 families in seven countries, found aggressive behaviour among Kenyan children had been rising before the ban but began declining afterwards.

In Kenya, the researchers followed 100 families, comparing children’s behaviour before and after the prohibition of corporal punishment. The other countries included Colombia, Italy, Jordan, the Philippines, Thailand and the United States.

The findings challenge the argument that physical punishment is necessary to keep children in check, suggesting removing the cane does not automatically leave them without boundaries or make them more aggressive.

“The present findings … demonstrate that a national legal ban on corporal punishment is related not only to a decrease in children's experience of corporal punishment but also to a decrease in child aggression,” the researchers said.

Published on November 11 in the 'Child Abuse & Neglect journal, the study is titled Child aggression before and after a national ban on corporal punishment: A longitudinal, cross-national study'.

Among its authors is Paul Oburu, an associate professor in the department of educational psychology at Maseno University. Other researchers are affiliated with foreign universities, including Duke University and the University of Massachusetts Amherst in the United States.

To establish how children’s behaviour changed over time, the researchers asked children to complete the Youth Self Report Form of the Child Behaviour Checklist.

The questionnaire required them to assess how true different statements about their behaviour had been during the preceding six months.

These included vandalism, bullying, threatening to hurt others and physical aggression.

A higher score indicated more behaviour problems associated with aggression.

The results showed aggressive behaviour among Kenyan children increased by an average of 1.22 points annually between the ages of eight and 11, the period before the ban.

However, between the ages of 12 and 16, after the ban, aggression scores declined by an average of 0.59 points annually.

The researchers also examined whether the legal prohibition was accompanied by changes in how children were treated at home.

Mothers were asked whether they or another adult in the household had physically punished the child during the previous month.

The forms of punishment considered included shaking, spanking or slapping, hitting with an object such as a belt or stick, and striking the face, head or ears.

The study found children’s exposure to corporal punishment at home also declined after the ban.

The researchers said the results should offer reassurance to those who fear children will become more aggressive when physical punishment is removed.

“The findings should provide reassurance to skeptics who are concerned that child aggression might increase if it goes unchecked by corporal punishment,” the authors said.

They highlighted Kenya’s experience because the country did not accompany the legal prohibition with the kind of public awareness or education campaigns implemented in some other countries.

“The decrease in child aggression associated with the legal ban is especially notable because unlike in some countries that launched public awareness or education campaigns in conjunction with legal bans of corporal punishment, Kenya did not,” the report states.

The findings have implications for policymakers considering a return to corporal punishment as a response to indiscipline in schools.

“Results from the present study suggest that outlawing corporal punishment does not only serve the human rights goal of protecting children from violence by decreasing use of corporal punishment," the report says.

"Outlawing corporal punishment is also related to a decrease in child aggression, providing additional motivation for policymakers considering legal bans.”

The debate has gained fresh attention following calls by some MPs to review the prohibition amid concerns over student indiscipline and attacks on teachers.

National Assembly Education Committee chairman Julius Melly recently said a proposal to review the ban had been presented, questioning why teachers faced punishment for administering corporal punishment while students who assaulted teachers appeared to escape similar scrutiny.

“Why are we punishing the teacher for corporal punishment and everyone is quiet about the student?” he asked.

But education stakeholders have cautioned against returning to a practice they say was previously open to abuse.

Moses Wekono, chairman of the Unified APBET Schools Association-Kenya, said some teachers had exceeded reasonable disciplinary limits when corporal punishment was allowed.

“Reverting to corporal punishment might again complicate everything because of the Bill of Rights in the Constitution. Some teachers were overdoing corporal punishment because they were not very fair in administering it,” Wekono said.

Kenya outlawed corporal punishment in schools in 2001, with the prohibition subsequently reinforced through the Basic Education Act of 2013, the Children Act and constitutional protections.

The legal framework requires schools to uphold children’s dignity and protect them from physical and other forms of violence. Violations can attract a fine of up to Sh100,000 or imprisonment for up to six months.

Kenya is also a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, which obligates governments to protect children from all forms of violence, including mental violence.

The proposed Basic Education Bill, 2026, also retains protections for learners. Clause 19 protects them from corporal punishment, torture and cruel treatment.

The emerging debate, therefore, is not simply about whether teachers should be allowed to cane students again. It is also about how schools can enforce discipline while protecting children from violence.

For policymakers seeking to reverse the ban, the new research presents evidence they will have to contend with: in Kenya, the period following the prohibition was associated with a decline in aggressive behaviour among children, rather than the increase critics feared.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *