The Constitution, the Elections Act and judicial decisions establish the legal framework governing the electoral process, including the authority of the National Tallying Centre and the responsibilities of the Commission and its Chairperson.
Article 88(5) of the Constitution requires the IEBC to exercise its powers and perform its duties in accordance with the Constitution and national legislation. This means its mandate must be understood alongside laws governing the conduct of elections.
The IEBC's role in presidential elections
Article 138(3)(c) requires the IEBC to tally and verify votes counted at polling stations before declaring the presidential election results.
Article 138(10), on the other hand, gives the Chairperson the responsibility of declaring the presidential election result.
The two provisions assign different but complementary responsibilities. While the Chairperson is responsible for announcing the final outcome, tallying and verifying the results are responsibilities of the Commission as a whole.
What the Supreme Court said about tallying
The Supreme Court addressed the distinction in the 2022 presidential election petition, Raila Odinga & 16 others v Ruto & 10 others; Law Society of Kenya & 4 others (Amicus Curiae) [2022] KESC 56 (KLR.
The Court affirmed that national-level tallying and verification of presidential results are collective responsibilities of the IEBC, rather than functions the Chairperson can independently exercise.
This distinction is important because the Chairperson's authority to declare the results does not mean the entire tallying and verification process rests on one individual.
Why the National Tallying Centre is provided for in law
Section 39 of the Elections Act provides for the transmission, tallying and verification of election results through constituency and national tallying centres.
The National Tallying Centre is therefore part of the legal framework through which the IEBC fulfils its constitutional responsibilities. Its purpose includes the aggregation and verification of results, rather than changing results already declared at constituency level.
In Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 others [2017] eKLR, the Court of Appeal affirmed the finality of results declared by constituency returning officers.
The ruling distinguishes national tallying and verification from altering results already declared by constituency returning officers.
How presidential victory is determined
Article 138(4) sets out the requirements a presidential candidate must meet to win an election.
A candidate must secure more than half of all votes cast and at least 25 per cent of the votes cast in more than half of Kenya's counties.
Determining whether a candidate has met both thresholds requires the national aggregation and verification of results, making the national tallying process an essential part of the presidential election.
The High Court also addressed the legal basis of the National Tallying Centre in Okoiti & another v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 5 others [2026] KEHC 13916 (KLR), upholding the framework governing national tallying and verification.
The legal distinction remains that the IEBC collectively handles tallying and verification, while the Chairperson is tasked with declaring the final presidential result.
Respecting the boundaries of each institution's mandate is central to upholding the Constitution, protecting electoral integrity and maintaining public confidence in Kenya's democratic process.
Source

Leave a Reply