‘Who Has Bewitched You?’ Judge Reads Romantic Love Letter in Bitter Marriage Dispute

Written by

in

Justice Robinson Ondieki of the High Court used the letter to reflect on how relationships that begin with affection and high expectations can eventually end in bitter legal battles.

The case involved a foreign national identified in court documents as Dr F.A.T., who came to Kenya in 2019, met a Kenyan woman identified as G.K. and later married her.

The couple exchanged vows on February 20, 2021, at the Pentecostal Evangelistic Fellowship of Africa in Ruiru before settling at Kahawa Sukari. However, their marriage reportedly experienced serious difficulties within a short period.

During the court proceedings, Justice Ondieki revisited an old love letter filled with elaborate declarations of affection, unusual comparisons and romantic expressions.

The letter included phrases comparing the recipient to chocolate, describing her as an angel and using mathematical expressions to explain the writer's feelings.

One of its memorable lines read: "Tea needs sugar, bees need honey, and I need you."

The writer also borrowed a line from reggae musician Glen Washington, declaring: "If loving you is wrong, I do not want to be right!"

After reading the letter, the judge turned to the estranged couple and asked: "To the couple, who has bewitched you?"

His remarks highlighted the contrast between the romantic language of courtship and the difficult circumstances that had brought the couple before him.

According to the husband's account, the marriage was characterised by disagreements, emotional and financial abuse, and neglect.

He told the court that less than a year after the wedding, his wife allegedly moved out of their matrimonial home with furniture, fittings and other household items, leaving the house empty.

The couple did not have children.

Their separation eventually developed into a dispute over ownership of a house situated at Riverfront Estate in Ruiru.

The husband approached the court seeking a declaration that he was the sole owner of the property, arguing that he had paid the entire purchase price despite the house being registered in both their names.

His former wife acknowledged that she had not contributed money towards purchasing the property. However, she argued that she had made an indirect contribution by helping identify the house while her husband was outside the country.

She maintained that her involvement in finding the property should be considered when determining ownership and asked the court to dismiss her husband's application.

In determining the dispute, Justice Ondieki examined the meaning of contribution under the Matrimonial Property Act.

The law recognises that a spouse's contribution is not limited to direct financial payments. It can also include domestic work, managing the matrimonial home, childcare, companionship, managing family businesses or property, and farm work.

However, the judge found that the wife's involvement in identifying the property during their courtship did not amount to sufficient indirect contribution to establish an entitlement to ownership.

He therefore agreed that the house did not qualify as matrimonial property in the circumstances of the case.

The judge observed that the marriage had lasted only a short time, describing the period as a brief season comparable to the fading light of a candle.

Nevertheless, he noted that the short duration of a marriage does not automatically make the expectations created by the relationship insignificant.

After considering the evidence, the court declared the husband the sole owner of the Ruiru property.

Justice Ondieki directed that the house be registered in his name and ordered the wife to sign a unilateral liability release agreement to formally discharge her interest in the property.

The ruling highlights an important distinction in matrimonial property disputes: registration of a property in both spouses' names does not necessarily settle the question of beneficial ownership.

Courts must examine the nature and extent of each spouse's contribution before determining how property should be shared.

The decision also serves as a reminder that matrimonial property cases are assessed individually rather than through an automatic assumption that every asset acquired during a marriage must be divided equally.

Beyond the legal outcome, the judge's use of the old love letter brought an unusual human element to a case that had moved from romantic courtship to a courtroom battle over property.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *