Kenyan Moves to Court to Stop Cheptumo Ayabei’s Appointment as TSC CEO, Cites Irregularities

Written by

in

The appointment of Cheptumo Ayabei as the Teachers Service Commission (TSC) Chief Executive Officer has been challenged in court, with a petitioner seeking to have the recruitment process declared unconstitutional and cancelled over alleged irregularities.

Fredrick Bikeri filed a constitutional petition at the High Court in Nairobi on Tuesday, November 17, a day after TSC announced Ayabei's appointment. He wants the court to overturn the decision and compel the commission to conduct a fresh recruitment exercise.

In his petition, Bikeri questions how TSC narrowed down 124 applicants to just five candidates selected for interviews. The commission had advertised the vacancy on September 29, 2026, giving interested candidates until October 30 to submit their applications.

The petitioner argues that TSC did not disclose the evaluation criteria, scoring methodology or comparative assessment used to determine which applicants qualified for interviews.

He maintains that the lack of information raises concerns about whether candidates were shortlisted fairly and strictly on merit.

“The failure to disclose the evaluation criteria, scoring methodology and comparative assessment of the applicants creates a reasonable apprehension that the shortlisting process may have been arbitrary, discriminatory and/or influenced by considerations other than merit,” Bikeri stated in his court papers.

He has also questioned changes to the published interview schedule, claiming that candidates were initially informed that interviews would begin at 9am on November 16 before the timetable was altered.

According to Bikeri, the changes were made without adequate notification or explanation, potentially giving some applicants an unfair advantage.

The petitioner further alleges that Ayabei appeared to have undertaken certain duties associated with the CEO's office before his formal appointment. He claims this raised questions about whether the recruitment outcome had been predetermined.

“I have strong reasons to believe that the recruitment process was predetermined in favour of the Interested Party,” he stated in his supporting affidavit.

Bikeri wants the court to declare Ayabei's appointment unconstitutional, illegal, null and void and subsequently quash the decision.

He is also seeking orders requiring TSC to conduct a fresh recruitment exercise in accordance with the Constitution, the Teachers Service Commission Act and the Fair Administrative Action Act.

Additionally, he wants the commission compelled to release recruitment records, including shortlisting criteria, applicants' scores, interview evaluation matrices and the final recruitment report.

The petitioner has also asked the court to issue conservatory orders preventing Ayabei from assuming or exercising the functions of the CEO while the case is pending. He proposes that an acting CEO should oversee the commission's operations in the meantime.

TSC announced Ayabei's appointment on Monday, November 16, describing the recruitment exercise as competitive and conducted in accordance with the Constitution and the Teachers Service Commission Act.

Commission chairman Dr Jamleck Muturi John said the incoming CEO would provide strategic and administrative leadership to the institution.

However, the appointment now faces a legal challenge after Justice David Mburu certified the application as urgent. The judge directed TSC and Ayabei to file and serve their responses within three days of service.

The case is scheduled for mention on November 23, 2026, when the court is expected to confirm compliance and give further directions.

The petitioner's claims are yet to be determined by the court, and the commission and Ayabei have been directed to respond to the allegations.

Source

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *