The Education Ministry has suffered a setback after the High Court nullified a circular seeking to merge Early Childhood Development Education (ECDE) teacher training with primary teacher training.
The court ruled that the government had failed to demonstrate that adequate public participation was conducted before the policy was introduced.
In her judgment, Justice Patricia Mande declared the circular issued on January 19, 2026, unconstitutional, ruling that the ministry had not provided evidence to support its claims that it had consulted stakeholders before making the changes.
The judge found that although the national government has the constitutional authority to formulate education policies, the exercise of that mandate must comply with constitutional requirements, including public participation.
The dispute arose after the Ministry of Education, through the State Department for Basic Education, issued a circular dated January 19, 2026, communicating the changes to the training programmes.
The Kenya Union of Pre-Primary Education Teachers challenged the decision, arguing that the ministry had interfered with the constitutional mandate of the Teachers Service Commission (TSC), which is responsible for reviewing standards of education and training for persons entering the teaching service.
The union also questioned the process through which the policy was developed, arguing that the government had failed to undertake adequate public participation before issuing the circular.
In her determination, Justice Mande considered whether the ministry had acted beyond its constitutional mandate and whether the process leading to the issuance of the circular met the required threshold for public participation.
On the question of the ministry's authority, the judge found that the national government was constitutionally mandated to develop education policies.
She relied on Article 186 of the Constitution, which provides for the distribution of functions between the national and county governments, and the Fourth Schedule, which assigns the national government responsibility for education policy, standards, curricula, examinations and the granting of university charters.
However, the judge emphasised that the exercise of that mandate was subject to Article 10 of the Constitution, which makes public participation a binding national value and principle of governance.
"The process of public participation ought not to be reduced to a mere symbolic box to keep ritual with no influence in the legislative process," she stated, referring to the Supreme Court's guidance.
Justice Mande further held that where a government policy is challenged for lack of public participation, the public authority responsible for its formulation bears the burden of demonstrating that the constitutional threshold was met.
She noted that although the ministry claimed to have conducted extensive nationwide consultations and engaged relevant stakeholders, it had failed to produce reports or records of those engagements before the court.
“In the absence of such evidence, the court can only draw one of two inferences: either the first respondent (education CS) has elected not to subject the process to constitutional scrutiny, or it is unable to controvert the petitioner's assertion that requisite public participation did not occur,” she observed.
“Whichever inference is drawn, the result is the same: the policy embodied in and communicated through the impugned circular is bereft of the constitutional foundation necessary to sustain it; lacking that constitutional anchor, it cannot stand and must consequently fall.”
She consequently quashed the policy.

Leave a Reply