IEBC, chairperson and national tallying centre: What does the law say?

Written by

in

I have been following the debate surrounding the IEBC, particularly the questions being raised about the authority of its Chairperson and the legal basis of the National Tallying Centre.

Think about this objectively: in a democracy governed by the rule of law, electoral questions must be examined through the Constitution, legislation and judicial precedent, not selective interpretations shaped by political interests.

The law is developed through constitutional provisions, legislation enacted by Parliament and judicial interpretation.

Courts apply and interpret these provisions, progressively developing jurisprudence that guides their application. These sources must be considered together when determining the legal position on electoral matters.

Article 259(1) of the Constitution requires it to be interpreted in a manner that promotes its purposes, values and principles, advances the rule of law and contributes to good governance. This demands a harmonious reading of the Constitution as a whole, rather than isolating individual provisions to advance particular arguments.

The debate must therefore be understood within this constitutional, statutory and jurisprudential context.

Article 88(5) requires the Commission to exercise its powers and perform its functions in accordance with the Constitution and national legislation. Its constitutional mandate must consequently be read alongside the Elections Act, which provides the statutory basis for administering elections.

Article 138(3)(c) requires the IEBC to tally and verify the votes counted at polling stations and declare the result. Article 138(10) assigns the Chairperson the responsibility of declaring the presidential election result.

These provisions establish distinct but complementary responsibilities. The Chairperson's authority to declare the result does not convert the Commission's collective responsibility for tallying and verification into an individual function.

The Supreme Court addressed this distinction in Raila Odinga & 16 others v Ruto & 10 others; Law Society of Kenya & 4 others (Amicus Curiae) [2022] KESC 56 (KLR). The Court affirmed that tallying and verification of presidential election results at the national level are collective responsibilities of the Commission, not functions exercisable by the Chairperson acting alone.

Section 39 of the Elections Act provides for the transmission, tallying and verification of election results through constituency and national tallying centres. The National Tallying Centre is therefore grounded in the statutory framework through which the IEBC fulfils its constitutional mandate.

In Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 others [2017] eKLR, the Court of Appeal affirmed the finality of results declared by constituency returning officers. National tallying and verification must therefore be distinguished from the alteration of constituency results.

The former does not give the Commission or its Chairperson administrative authority to reopen or alter results already declared.

The High Court, in Okoiti & another v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 5 others [2026] KEHC 13916 (KLR), also upheld the legal basis of the National Tallying Centre and the statutory provisions governing national tallying and verification.

The constitutional necessity of this process is reinforced by Article 138(4), which requires a presidential candidate to obtain more than half of all votes cast and at least 25 per cent of the votes cast in each of more than half of the counties.

Establishing whether these thresholds have been attained necessarily requires national aggregation and verification.

The legal position is that the IEBC collectively tallies and verifies presidential election results, while its Chairperson bears the specific responsibility of declaring the final outcome. These are complementary responsibilities expressly recognised by the Constitution and legislation, not competing mandates.

Our electoral jurisprudence has developed through the interpretation and application of these constitutional and statutory provisions. Judicial decisions are essential to understanding how the law operates in practice.

Political debate cannot displace this body of law, nor can constitutional provisions be invoked selectively while disregarding the legislation and judicial decisions that inform their application.

Respect for the Constitution must extend beyond its text to recognition of the authority vested in the institutions established under it.

Each institution has its own mandate, powers and limitations. Respecting these boundaries, alongside the decisions of competent courts, fosters harmony in governance, strengthens public confidence and sustains our democratic order.

The Constitution belongs to all Kenyans. Its authority and application must transcend political affiliations, electoral ambitions and individual interests.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *