Can Kenya account for every civil servant on the payroll?

Written by

in

Every month, the Treasury releases billions of shillings to pay Kenya’s public servants. The most basic test of any employer is whether it knows who is receiving that money. On the evidence of its own audits, the Kenyan government does not.

The Public Service Commission (PSC) found in its 2024 compliance report that staff registers carried 17,000 more names than there were officers in post. Kenya Railways listed 3,287 employees; only 2,026 were at work. The Kenya Broadcasting Corporation had 231 ghost workers and State House 156 unposted staff. A separate forensic audit commissioned by the Ministry of Public Service has since flagged Sh6.2 billion in suspected payroll fraud: duplicate salaries, many employees sharing one bank account, altered records, and people listed as employed before they were born.

These are not clerical slips. Nobody is hired before birth by accident. As an accountant, I can say plainly that a payroll does not fill itself with fiction. Every false entry is keyed, approved and paid by someone with access to the system.

The counties tell the same story. Vihiga’s own human resource audit found ghost workers earning Sh32 million a month. Lamu probed 112 names that had drawn salaries for years. In Garissa, 321 names with no personnel files were still issued Unique Personal Numbers, the very control meant to keep ghosts out. The Controller of Budget has reported counties paying Sh2 billion in salaries outside the official payroll system in a single quarter.

Kenyans have heard this before. Every administration has promised to purge the payroll, and every fresh audit finds the same schemes under new names. Striking a few names off the list does not end a fraud that has run for years.

The present crackdown is the right instinct. In May, Public Service Cabinet Secretary Geoffrey Ruku directed all government institutions onto a single, tamper-proof human resource system. In July he handed the audit to the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI), which is verifying the personal numbers of 1,054,425 national and county employees. The World Bank has made payroll cleanup a condition of budget support worth about Sh94 billion. Outside pressure of that kind often makes governments finish what they start.

But software will not save us. Systems are run by people, and the people who manage payrolls are often the ones who profit from them. CS Ruku has himself admitted that cartels have infiltrated the public service. The Union of Kenya Civil Servants goes further, alleging that the fraud begins at the PSC, where fictitious employees are approved. That is an allegation, not a finding, and the commission deserves the chance to answer it. It also deserves an independent inquiry rather than a denial.

Some will argue that the numbers are overstated. The 17,000 figure compares registers with officers found in post, and some flagged entries will prove to be poor record-keeping, staff on leave or transfers not yet captured. That is fair. But it is an argument for publishing more, not less. If most flagged names are innocent, the government loses nothing by showing the reconciliation. If they are not, the public is entitled to know.

Those who expose the fraud have paid for it. Reports describe whistleblowers facing demotion, transfer, threats and, in some documented cases, violence. A government serious about its payroll cannot leave them exposed.

The ask is specific. The DCI and the Ministry of Public Service should publish how many flagged entries have been confirmed as fraud, how much has been recovered and how much remains unaccounted for. The Director of Public Prosecutions should charge the officers who created, approved and protected ghost names; a ghost cannot be prosecuted, but the people who built it can. Parliament should give payroll whistleblowers real protection in law. And the Controller of Budget should approve no salary release for any ministry, agency or county still paying staff outside the central system.

Kenya will be able to say it accounts for every civil servant when each salary can be traced to a verified person, in a funded post, paid into that person’s own account, and an independent auditor can confirm it year after year. That day has not come. Until the people who built the ghost payroll are convicted, every new audit will end the same way: a bigger number, a fresh promise and public money paid to people who do not exist.

CPA Enock Nyanchoga Monari is Managing Partner, Burmon Global Consulting.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *