Court declares ECDE, primary teacher training combination unconstitutional

Written by

in

Court declares ECDE, primary teacher training combination unconstitutional

A Milimani High Court has declared a Ministry of Education circular combining the Diploma in Early Childhood Teacher Education (DECTE) with the Diploma in Primary Teacher Education (DPTE) into a single programme unconstitutional.

The ministry’s circular, which combined the two diplomas, was renamed the Diploma in Teacher Education – Pre-Primary and Primary (DTE PP & P).

In a judgement delivered by Justice Patricia Nyaundi on Thursday, November 19, 2026, the court has stated that the said circular has no legal effect.

Justice Nyaundi has stated that the Ministry of Education has the mandate to develop policy, which is enshrined in the Constitution.

However, she has noted that the imperative law under Article 10 of the Constitution is that the development of such a policy must be preceded by public participation.

The court has found that the Ministry of Education did not conduct a public participation exercise before the merging of the same.

“The first respondent (Ministry of Education) asserts that the extensive nationwide consultations were conducted and that relevant stakeholders were engaged,” Judge Nyaundi stated.

“However, despite those assertions, the first respondent (Ministry of Education) has not placed before the court the reports or records of the consultations referred to in the replying affidavit,” the judge adds.

She has noted that in the absence of such evidence, the court can only draw one of two inferences: either the Ministry of Education has elected not to subject the process to constitutional scrutiny, or it is unable to controvert the petitioner’s assertion that requisite public participation did not occur.

Following the findings of the court that the Ministry of Education did not prove that it conducted the public participation exercise, the court has declared the circular unconstitutional.

“A declaration hereby issues that the circular dated January 19, 2026, reference number QAS/ECDE/7/1B/2/193 issued by the Ministry of Education State Department for the Basic Education Office of the principal sector is unconstitutional and therefore null and void and of no legal effect,” Judge Nyaundi stated.

“An order of such error is hereby issued removing it into this court for purposes of being quashed, and hereby quashes the circular dated January 19, 2026, reference number QAS/ECDE/7/1B/2/193.”

She further noted that there shall be no order to cost since the matter was filed in the public interest.

A journalist by profession and a lawyer by mindset, I report with precision, clarity, and integrity. My work focuses on telling stories as they are – grounded in fact, supported by evidence, and written in a language everyone can understand, free of jargon. I cover stories others often avoid, guided by a commitment to truth. If I didn’t report it, it didn’t happen! You can reach me at: zipporah.ngwatu@mediamax.ke

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *